People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Great service and great pizza highly recommended stopping by ”
“ This is a very unique pizza in that it has a taste and flavor all it's own thin yet packs a lot of flavor the best pepperoni and mushroom pie in this area very pleasing to the palate. I also enjoy getting onions as a topping or even a plain pie. Theres a reason this pizzeria has been around for 40 plus years. ”
“ Ordered 2 larges pizza pies, one pepperoni and the other sweet peppers and onions. Amazing, thinner pizza, crunchy crust. The pepperoni is what brings be back, its thin sliced but big. Family atmosphere and little hole in the wall style building. Cash only for anyone going to check it out! Highly recommend any day of the week. Call ahead on Friday's they get busy. They also sell a few adult drinks as well. :) ”
“ Shoutout to Ms Shelley. Always so kind even when its 120 degrees in and outside. She’s the best and so is her pizza. Not only is it delicious but it’s at a great price. ”
“ I always liked their pizza but lately it’s been better than ever. Definitely my top choice. ”
“ Delicious. How do they get so much flavor from such a thin pizza? I'll be back. ”
“ I have to say, I've had Shelly's before and never really enjoyed it. However, my family got some for the Super Bowl and I was highly impressed. Not sure if they changed their recipe, but it just hit different. The cheese blend was very flavorful, and the crust was cooked well but not over crunchy. The sauce did its job, nothing impressive. Pizza was a solid 7.5/10. ”
“ Really delicious steak stromboli! Ordered mine w/ everything (steak/cheese/onions/sweet peppers). Large comes with 2 large cups of marinara sauce, I got mild banana peppers on the side as well. As others said, it does look very "flat" but the flavor is on point! The texture of the crust is soft and chewy in the inside but slightly crunchy on the outside. Even if it gets a little soggy, it's delish. Pizza is Def similar to an NYC style flavor and crust! Similar crust to the boli...and the price was right. Def will be back! ”
About
Shelley's Pizza
Welcome to the delightful world of Shelley's Pizza, a beloved gem nestled in the heart of Wilkes-Barre, PA. Located at 641 Carey Ave, this pizzeria has been serving the community for over 40 years, standing the test of time with its exceptional offerings and warm service. With a phone contact of +1 570-826-1234, it's easy to reach out and place an order or inquire about their menu.
What sets Shelley's Pizza apart? It all begins with their distinctive thin-crust pies, expertly crafted to create a crisp yet satisfying base. The moment you sink your teeth into their pizza, you’ll discover a burst of flavor that is truly unique. Patrons often rave about the pepperoni and mushroom combination, with one satisfied customer praising it as "the best in the area." With each bite, you'll appreciate the harmonious balance of toppings, from the savory pepperoni to the fresh mushrooms, creating a pizza experience that's both flavorful and pleasing to the palate.
The cozy, family-friendly atmosphere adds to the charm of this hole-in-the-wall establishment. Regulars appreciate the personal touch provided by Ms. Shelley herself, whose kindness shines even on the hottest days. Her dedication to quality and service has garnered many loyal customers, further solidifying Shelley's Pizza as a local favorite.
Customers frequently recommend the toppings, particularly the sweet peppers and onions, which beautifully complement the classic flavors. And if you're a fan of a simplified approach to pizza, their plain pie is equally noteworthy. Each dish is made with care and precision, making it no surprise why new and returning patrons alike highlight the overall improvement in quality over the years.
Though they embrace a cash-only policy, the experience at Shelley's Pizza is worth every dollar. Don't forget to call ahead, especially on busy Fridays, to secure your own slice of heaven. Shelley's Pizza isn’t just a restaurant; it’s a culinary tradition beloved by many, and a must-try for those looking for a slice of authentic pizza bliss.
Book a table